By Maximilian Clarke
Proposals put forward by the Ministry of Justice to introduce fees for industrial tribunal claimants, which have been welcomed by business organisations, have been blasted by the Trades Union Congress as an affront to the rights of the UK’s poorest workers.
The head of Employment Policy at the Institute of Directors dubbed the tribunal fee proposal ‘well-judged’, whilst Katya Hall, Chief Policy Director at the Confederation of British Industry added that adding that they would reduce costly, vexatious claims, helping the system better evaluate genuine rights breaches.
However, Brenden Barber, General Secretary of the TUC attacked the proposals with the following comments:
“Employment tribunals are a key way of enabling workers to enforce their rights. Government proposals to introduce a fee to lodge an initial claim - and then possibly a further charge for a full hearing - will effectively prevent the poorest and most vulnerable workers from ever being able to get justice.
“It is completely unacceptable that a worker on the minimum wage, who has been underpaid and denied holiday pay, may now have to pay a fee of £250 or more to claim back what they are entitled to because their employer flouted the law.
“Because the fees will be paid upfront and only refunded if a claim succeeds, the poorest workers and those without union backing will struggle to pay these costs. They are also the most likely to be deterred from pursuing a claim - especially as a high proportion of workers who win cases can struggle to recover the money owed by the employer. It is likely that many legitimate claims will be deterred, enabling rogue employers to act with impunity.
“Ministers say that it is right that workers using the employment tribunal service should pay for it, but they fail to consider that the reason workers have to resort to using the tribunal service in the first place is because their employers have failed to abide by the law.
“Levying higher fees on claims above £30,000 will penalise workers bringing discrimination claims, and in particular those who have suffered from the most blatant forms of prejudice.
“Rather than focus on denying workers the opportunity to pursue legitimate claims, the government should be ensuring that all workers are able to enforce their rights and should be directing its attention to tackling the rogue employers who behave as if they are above the law.”
Join us on