The UK is no longer the second slowest economy in the G7 and EU so far this year. Instead, it is the second slowest, at least among the countries for which we have data.
It is an odd thing. While the headlines across the media focus on the latest job figures, which were pretty much the same as last month, which were pretty much the same as the month before, the real economics story of 2017 is missed.
We don’t yet have all the data for all of the EU and G7 for the third quarter of 2017. But we do have most of it. And as things currently stand, the slowest growing economy so far this year is Denmark, cumulative growth so far this year is 0.9 per cent. The UK, by contrast has grown by one per cent.
We are still awaiting data for how the Irish economy did in the Q3, but so far we have seen a somewhat peculiar performance . It grew by a stunning 5.8 per cent in Q4 of last year, and contracted by 3.5 per cent in Q1, and then grew by 1.4 per cent in Q2. There are so many one-off factors at work in Ireland, its growth rate trajectory correlating so much with a roller-coaster, that we should perhaps exclude the economy from the growth league for the time-being, and revise again when we have the full data for the year as a whole.
We don’t have data yet for Luxembourg, Estonia, Greece, Malta, Slovenia and Sweden.
Of these countries, Luxembourg has had a poor year so far, and final data may reveal it is behind the UK, and Greece only grew marginally more quickly than the UK in Q1 and Q2, so a poor third quarter will see it fall behind the UK.
But looking at the world’s larger economies, the UK is lagging, at bottom place.
|Percentage growth in GDP in 2017, source Eurostat|
Or see it this way
This all begs the question why?Why has the UK seen such a poor year?
Here are two possible explanations.
- It is just the timing of the cycle, the UK topped the chart for much of the two previous years, and in 2017 it is simply its turn to fall to bottom.
- Brexit related factors, namely the fall in sterling pushing up on inflation and down on real wages and reluctance by companies to invest in light of Brexit related uncertainty.
When people argue that the Brexit vote has had no discernible effect on the UK economy, it seems that they arguing black equals white.